Skip to the content
TTHINRIDGE Audit your trades Test your strategy free

You asked, we ran

Under every post, someone asks what happens if you change one thing. We run it as they said it, write down what we expect before it runs, and post the numbers, misses included. Newest first.

Run and written up by J. Berkowitz, for Edgeproof LLC. Who signs what

Yours: describe it on the form, free, or by email to audits@thinridge.io.

Each answer here was run on the data of its day, to August 14, 2026. Since November 2 the shelf runs to October 30, 2026, so a setup’s own page can show other numbers: the plain opening range breakout on NQ scored 28 then and scores 23 now (on the data to October 30, and since November 16 with the engine’s fix for days the market closes early).

“Only take the breakout when it’s past the premarket range”

A reader on r/Daytrading. The opening range breakout on NQ, only the breaks already past the overnight high or low (6 PM the evening before to 9:30), then the same rule, unchanged, on ten other markets. November 1.

On NQ it went from 28 to 80: 1,827 trades, +$228,887, and +$98,063 before 2023, with only 45 of 5,000 coin flips doing as well. It came out Close, not Passed: before 2023 most of its money came in 2008, 2021 and 2022, and the twelve years between made about $7,700. Then the honest test: the same rule on ten other markets. It failed on every one; the best was ES at 30.

Before the runWhat happened
On NQ it doesn’t turn the breakout into a pass.hit80, Close: one check held it back.
On the other markets it raises the score on at least 7 of 10.miss6 of 10, and only from failing to failing less.
On ES, YM and RTY it scores 50 or more on two of the three.miss30, 20 and 12.
It passes on none of the ten.hitNone.

Predictions filed before each run: 2 of 4 held.

What it means: the best idea a reader has brought us so far, and still NQ’s own years, not a rule that travels. A good question with an honest answer is worth asking: send yours.

“If the opening range high forms first, target the low”

A post on X, about 10,000 views: six months of NQ, “68% probability of sweeping the low”. Checked on 4,642 NQ sessions, 2008 to August 2026, November 1.

Read as the range’s high printing before its low, the low was taken out later that day on 87% of those days. That sounds strong until you look at an ordinary day: the low gets taken out on 75% of all days anyway, and the mirror is just as strong (the low prints first, the high gets taken 89%). Read as the high breaking out first after 9:45, the low was taken out later only 52% of the time; the mirror 55%. The 68% depended on “aggressive selling”, which the post doesn’t define, so that number itself can’t be checked.

Before the runWhat happened
Read as the high printing first: the low swept on 45% to 70% of those days.miss87% (1,968 of 2,272). Much higher than expected.
Every day, the low swept within 8 points of that.miss75%, 12 points lower. The difference is real.
Read as the high breaking first: the low swept later on 20% to 55%.hit52% (1,233 of 2,395).
The mirror (low breaks first, high swept) within 8 points.hit55%.

Predictions filed before the run: 2 of 4 held. We expected the order inside the range not to matter; it matters a lot.

What it means: it isn’t about the high. Whichever end of the range printed last, price is sitting right next to it at 9:45, and nearby levels get revisited. If you trade it, you’re trading that, in both directions.

“The retest only counts on less volume than the breakout”

A reader on r/Daytrading, then his number: under 35% of the breakout candle. The shelf’s opening-range retest on NQ and ES, one-minute bars with their volume, November 1.

With the retest bar on less volume than the breakout bar, about a quarter of the retests drop out on each market. On NQ the 15 years before 2023 go from −$2,674 to +$8,225 over 2,312 trades, under one tick a trade, with the ORB’s shape: 2008 to 2020 lost $93,822 and 2021 and 2022 made it back. On ES they go from −$95,892 to −$72,095. Under 35% leaves a retest that quiet on about 6% of retests (226 trades on NQ in 18 years); on those days it lost before 2023 on both markets (−$1,680 NQ, −$16,309 ES).

Before the runWhat happened
Less volume: NQ fails.hit26 of 100.
Less volume: ES fails.hit11 of 100.
It keeps half to 85% of the retests.hit73% on NQ, 72% on ES.
On NQ, at least 1,000 of 5,000 coin flips do as well before 2023.hit1,308.
On ES it loses before 2023.hit−$72,095.
Under 35%: fewer than half the retests left.hit6% and 7%.
Under 35%: NQ fails.hit25.
Under 35%: ES fails.hit14.
Under 35%: on NQ at least 1,000 coin flips as good.hit2,233.

Predictions filed before each run: 5 of 5, then 4 of 4.

What it means: volume helps the retest a little on NQ, not enough to make it a strategy on its own, and asking for a much quieter retest leaves too few days to matter.

“The ORB is seasonal, you can’t judge it by the year”

A reader on r/Daytrading. The ORB on NQ’s own trades, split by calendar month, November 1.

From 2008 to 2022 the ORB on NQ lost money in 6 of the 12 months. Of the 6 months that made money then (March, April, May, September, October, December), only April made real money again since 2023 (+$48,000); October made $424, and the other four lost.

No prediction: this was read from the trades already on file, not a new run.

What it means: the good months didn’t repeat. A season you can only see after the fact isn’t one you can trade.

“If direction adds nothing, flip every trade”

A reader on r/Daytrading, under the ORB with a stop and a 2R target. The same 4,708 trades on NQ, each taken the other way, same stop and target distances, November 1.

Flipped, the trades lost $13,469 from 2008 to 2022 and $88,440 since. The breakout made $1,081 and $134,825. Before 2023, 2,713 of 5,000 coin flips did as well as the flip and 2,213 as well as the breakout: both sit in the middle of the coin flips.

Before the runWhat happened
The flip lands in the middle 80% of the coin flips before 2023.hit−$13,469, inside −$82,714 to +$70,656.
The flip loses before 2023.hit−$13,469.
The flip loses since 2023.hit−$88,440.
The flip loses over all 18 years.hit−$101,909.

Predictions filed before the run: 4 of 4 held.

What it means: before 2023 neither side made money after costs, which is what “direction adds nothing” looks like. Since 2023 the side mattered: the last three years are a trend the breakout caught.

“What about with a stop and a 2R target?”

The question readers ask most about the ORB. NQ, 18 years, three versions beside the plain one, October 31. The ORB page carries all four →

With a stop at the other side of the range and a 2R target, the ORB on NQ made $135,906 and scores 50, Close. But its 15 years before 2023 made $1,081 over 3,783 trades, 29 cents a trade, under one tick; 2008 to 2020 lost $72,867, and 2021 and 2022 made it back. 2,213 of 5,000 coin flips with the same stop and target did as well. The plain version, no stop and no target, made $33,611 and failed, 28.

Before the runWhat happened
All three versions fail.missThe 2R version scored 50, Close.
On each, more than 250 of 5,000 coin flips as good before 2023.hit2,479, 3,723 and 2,213.
2R nets less than 1R.miss2R $135,906; 1R $8,126.
None is positive before 2023.miss2R +$1,081.

Predictions filed before the run: 1 of 4 held. Our miss: a run from August had already shown 2R beating 1R, and the predictions were filed without reading it.

What it means: a stop and a target change what it made from 2023 on. They don’t change the fifteen years before.