What to send
The strategy the way the seller says it. “Buy the first close above the opening range, out at the bell” is enough; so is the code, if you have it (NinjaScript, Python, Pine or Thinkscript). If it’s a course, send the setup the way it’s taught, and where the teaching leaves a choice open, say what you’d do; the Silver Bullet page shows what that looks like written down.
What comes back
One report: a score from 0 to 100 and a verdict; what the strategy did on 2008 to 2022, the years kept apart from the ones since (if the seller built or tuned it on those years, a pass there is in-sample: the months since you bought it are the real test); how many of 5,000 coin flips did as well; how much slippage it survives; how much of the money came from one trade or one year; and the longest stretch you’d have sat without a new high.
Where this fits
Between the day you first see a setup work and the day you put real size on it. Most traders test with money, small at first, and scale what holds. This is the step in the middle: eighteen years of it, before the small size.
Famous setups, already run
Our first six reports: five on the data to August 14, 2026, the first by hand on 2010 to 2025; each page keeps its numbers as they came out then. The 50 setups on the shelf were all tested the same way on data to October 30, 2026; look there first for the one you are about to pay for.
The bullish engulfing candle, as taught: 2,853 trades on ES, failed 16/100, the hand study that started the series.
The 15-minute opening range breakout: 4,708 trades on NQ, failed 28/100, the edge all since 2023. Run in August on data to August 14; the shelf ran it again on data to October 30: 4,762 trades, 18.
The morning move: on NQ, run again on data to October 30, 716 trades, passed 90/100, and 46 months without a new high.
The Keltner channel fade: 4,801 trades on NQ, failed 11/100, never above zero.
The ORB on Fridays only: 925 trades on NQ, 85/100 but held at Close, because it was found on the seventh try.
The Silver Bullet, written as a strategy: 2,372 trades on NQ, failed 13/100, 14 of the 15 years before 2023 lost.
What it can’t do
It can’t test a read. If the edge is “you’ll know it when you see it,” there is no strategy to run, and no test on earth can score that except your own account. It can’t know what the seller left out. And a strategy that passes here can still be one you’d quit on in a slow year; the report shows you those years so that’s your decision, not a surprise.
Every run and every report, no card. Private unless you choose to publish.
Questions people ask
Do you review courses or bots? No. We run the strategy inside them. A review is an opinion; this is 18 years of trades.
What if the seller won’t give me the strategy? Then you’re being sold a read, not a strategy, and nothing can test a read. That’s worth knowing before the card goes through.
Will my result be published? Only if you choose. Every run is private unless you choose Publish on Readers’ strategies on the form, and it never shows your name.
What if I trade it with a stop and a target? Say so. Stops and targets are part of the strategy and get tested with it; on the Silver Bullet the usual 10-point stop made it worse.