The strategy
Spend a week in any prop-firm Discord and you will see it drawn on a chart. Mark the high and low of the first fifteen minutes from 9:30 ET. On the first one-minute close outside that range, go with it, no later than 11:30. Both directions. Flat at 15:30 ET by market order — 2:30 Chicago, well before any funded-account close-out, so nothing here depends on an exit a funded account could not take. No stop, no target, one contract, NQ.
Nothing else. No volume condition, no trend filter, no “only on gap days.” That is the strategy as submitted through the public form on August 21, 2026, declared as version #1 with a seen-from year of 2023. It was scored by the engine, not by a person, and the report it received is the same report a stranger receives.
Readers of this page have said, fairly, that nobody trades a breakout without a stop. Correct — and the no-stop version is still tested first, on purpose. You cannot measure what a stop adds until you know what the signal is worth without one. A stop and a target are a change to the strategy, not a detail, and the engine scores a bracketed version as a second strategy shown beside the first. The bracketed forms of this strategy — one-to-one and two-to-one, stop at the far side of the range — were run, and the table is below.
The verdict
28 out of 100. Failed. Gate G7, era-manufactured edge. Four of six pillars below half credit.
The headline number that sells this strategy is real: 4,708 trades since 2008, net +$33,611 after $14.20 per round trip. The number underneath it is the one that matters. Seen years are the ones the submitter declared he had looked at while building the strategy, 2023 on; unseen years are the fifteen before, and they decide the verdict.
| Era | Years | Trades | Net result |
|---|---|---|---|
| Unseen (2008–2022) | 15 | 3,783 | −$19,979 |
| Seen, as declared (2023–2026) | 3.6 | 925 | +$53,590 |
It lost money for fifteen years and then made all of it, and more, in the years the submitter said he was looking at. That is the G7 signature: unseen expectancy negative, seen expectancy positive and more than three times its size.
Year by year, unseen era
| Year | Net | Year | Net |
|---|---|---|---|
| 2008 | +$8,511 | 2016 | −$10,248 |
| 2009 | −$8,884 | 2017 | −$16,606 |
| 2010 | −$7,758 | 2018 | −$1,992 |
| 2011 | −$5,055 | 2019 | +$6,408 |
| 2012 | −$1,668 | 2020 | −$50,971 |
| 2013 | −$5,053 | 2021 | +$35,684 |
| 2014 | +$2,517 | 2022 | +$51,960 |
| 2015 | −$16,823 |
Five of fifteen years positive. 2020, the year everyone remembers as the breakout year, was the worst year this strategy ever had. 2021 and 2022 produced $87,644 between them, and that is where the whole story lives. Remove those two years and the unseen era is −$107,623.
Compared to what? The coin-flip test
The engine runs five thousand twins. Each twin takes the same trades on the same days with the same costs and flips a coin for direction. If “go with the break” carries information, the strategy should beat most of its twins.
Full window: p = 0.23. About one twin in four did as well or better by flipping coins. Unseen era, which governs: p = 0.34. One in three.
Where the money actually went
Net is 33% of gross at one tick per side. Two-thirds of what this strategy makes, it hands to the exchange and the spread. At two ticks per side it is −$13,469; at three, −$60,549. Breakeven is 1.7 ticks per side. NQ is quoted one tick wide for most of the day. This strategy lives inside the spread.
Concentration: the top trade is 94% of net. One trade. The top five are 243% of net; without them the strategy is underwater. A bootstrap of five thousand resampled histories puts the unseen-era net between −$182,000 and +$146,000, with P(net > 0) = 0.41.
Livability
The score says whether the edge is real. This section says whether a person could have held it. No points attach.
| Longest stretch without a new equity high | 185 months (ending June 2024) |
| Rolling 12-month windows that lost money | 61% of 213 |
| Worst 12 months | −$65,801 (ending Feb 2021) |
| Maximum drawdown, from the highest point before it to the Feb 2022 low | $149,706 |
| Median year | −$1,751 |
| Years of median to recoup the drawdown | n/a — the typical year recoups nothing |
| Share of all profit from the best two years | 261% |
Nobody holds a strategy through fifteen and a half years of new lows. The only way to have collected the 2021–22 money was to have started in 2021, and the only way to have started in 2021 was to have looked at 2021 first.
What passed
Parameter sensitivity scored 15 of 15. Move the range length or the entry cutoff ten percent in either direction and the result is the same. This strategy is not fragile. It is robustly nothing. Stable parameters around a coin flip are still a coin flip.
Verdict
FAILED — 28/100. Gate G7 tripped: the strategy’s edge exists only in the era its submitter declared as seen. The data was clean (6,180,656 bars, zero anomalies), the fills were honest (next-bar-open market orders, one tick adverse per side), and the result reproduces from the strategy text above. The evidence is valid. It says no.
Reproducibility
Anyone with NQ 1-minute data for 2008–2026 and the strategy as written above should land within Protocol tolerance (±10%) of 4,708 trades and +$33,611 net at $4.20 commission and one tick per side. The full engine report, number 9e1416fc6a, is on file. If you run it and land materially elsewhere, write to audits@thinridge.io.
Questions people ask
Does the opening range breakout work on NQ? Over the full 18 years, 4,708 trades made $33,611 after costs, and all of it came from 2023 on. The fifteen years before that lost $19,979, with 5 of 15 years positive. It is rejected on gate G7: an edge manufactured by the recent era.
How does it compare to a coin flip? 34% of 5,000 random-direction twins, taking the same days at the same costs, did as well or better. A strategy with an edge should leave almost none of them ahead of it.
What does slippage do to it? The result reaches zero at 1.7 ticks per side. At two ticks of slippage a side, which is ordinary on a fast open, it loses money.
Does it work better on some days of the week? Yes, and the split is the whole story: Fridays alone made $141,740 over 18 years and Wednesdays lost $108,292. The Friday-only version is Teardown No. 5.
Methods honesty — the correction ledger
- This page was built from the engine’s own report, not from a human re-run. The Protocol version was v1.1 in draft when this page went up (signed August 22, 2026); two rubric corrections found by running this very strategy (efficiency credit on a losing unseen era; the 100-unseen-trade minimum) were applied before the 28 was printed. An earlier draft of the rubric had printed 36.
- The engine report’s section 1 prints the locked strategy twice (wizard block and engine block). Cosmetic; logged.
What this cannot tell you
The score assumes this strategy walked in once, and that the submitter’s development did not touch 2008–2022. Neither was sworn. If you trade a version with a filter on it, submit it: a filter is scored as a second strategy and the report shows base and filtered side by side.
What readers asked for, and what it did
Three requests came in on the public thread. Each was run on the strategy above, same data, same costs, same engine, reconciled to this page’s 4,708 trades and +$33,611 before anything was posted. Unseen p is the share of 5,000 coin-flip twins that matched or beat the strategy on 2008–2022.
| Exit | Trades | Net, full | Net, unseen | Unseen p | Win |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| No stop, flat 15:30 ET (this page) | 4,708 | +$33,611 | −$19,979 | 0.343 | 49.7% |
| Stop one range-width away, no target | 4,708 | +$154,946 | +$16,396 | 0.406 | 39.0% |
| Same stop, target 1R | 4,708 | +$13,841 | −$73,404 | 0.683 | 49.4% |
| Same stop, target 2R | 4,708 | +$142,921 | +$12,346 | 0.421 | 41.3% |
| 25-point stop, 50-point target | 4,708 | −$40,414 | −$35,909 | 0.388 | 41.0% |
A stop makes the money bigger and the edge smaller. Stop-only is the best number in the study, and its unseen p is worse than no stop at all, because the coin-flip twins got the same stop and it cut their losers too. A wide stop in a market that went up for fifteen years helps everyone; it does not make the entry smarter. The 1:1 target is the destroyer it always is.
| Filter | Trades | Net, full | Net, unseen | Unseen p |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| All days (this page) | 4,708 | +$33,611 | −$19,979 | 0.343 |
| Longs only | 2,421 | +$103,622 | +$16,225 | 0.229 |
| Shorts only | 2,287 | −$70,010 | −$36,204 | 0.555 |
| Skip FOMC statement days (154, verified against federalreserve.gov) | 4,558 | +$73,171 | −$7,021 | 0.307 |
| Skip Mondays and Fridays | 2,847 | −$120,042 | −$99,418 | 0.833 |
| Skip Mon, Fri, and FOMC | 2,699 | −$86,391 | −$92,369 | 0.823 |
The plain strategy is a long strategy, which in a market that went from 2,000 to 25,000 is not a discovery, and neither side alone beats the twins. Skipping FOMC days was the one filter that helped the money: those 150 days lost $39,560 on their own. It moved p by three hundredths. Every one of these cuts is one more look at the same data, and the lineage on any page built from them would say so.
If you trade this by eye
Against 5,000 coin flips the written strategy is a coin (1,716 of 5,000 matched or beat it on the unseen years); whatever you do on top of the written steps is where any edge is, and your fills are how to find out which part.
A course, a bot, a signal room, or an evaluation you’d trade it in: run the strategy as the seller states it through the same test before the card goes through. Read this before you buy it →
Run your version
Trade a variant of it? Write it down in numbers and run it on the form: every run is free, and private unless you choose to publish. A variant the form can’t express can go by mail to audits@thinridge.io; the first one by mail is free too.