Skip to the content
TTHINRIDGE Audit your trades Test your strategy free

The shelf · Break of structure · Crude Oil WTI

Break of structure on CL

32Failedout of 100

Short answer: no, it does not pass. Break of structure on CL, tested by Thinridge on 18.8 years of one-minute Crude Oil WTI futures data (2008 to 2026) with costs on every trade, lost $64,263 net for one contract over 2,889 trades; 127 of 5,000 coin-flip copies of it (the same trades, the side picked at random) did as well or better on the years before 2023. Verdict: Failed, 32 of 100.

Where it breaks, and what to change ↓

Swing highs and lows of 5 bars each side on 5-minute bars, known once the bars after them have closed. In a rising structure the first close above the latest swing high buys, in a falling one below the latest swing low sells, with the stop past the latest swing on the other side. Between 9:45 AM and 3:00 PM; out at 3:30 PM. Run on CL, the Crude Oil WTI. Times are New York time.

swings 5 bars each sidebreak with the structurewindow 9:45 AM–3:00 PMout 3:30 PMstop past the setup's extreme · no targetbars 5-minfollowlong and short
What these settings mean
  • follow: trades in the direction of the break or signal.
  • long and short: takes both buys and sells.
  • window: a new trade can start only between these two times.
  • out: any trade still open is closed at this time.
  • stop past the setup’s extreme: a stop-loss just beyond the setup’s own high (for a sell) or low (for a buy); no profit target.
  • bars: the setup is read on bars of this many minutes.
  • swings: a swing high (or low) is a bar with this many lower highs (or higher lows) on each side of it.
  • The other settings are the setup’s own; the sentence above says what they do.

Tested as written above: a stop one tick past the extreme the setup names, no target, out at 3:30 PM. A different stop or target is a different strategy, with its own result: Test your version →

Hypothetical backtest: one contract, after costs, not real trading. Simulated results have limits: they are not actual trading, they are made with the benefit of hindsight, and no account is likely to achieve results like these. The standard statement

2,889trades, 18.8 years
-$64,263net after costs; -$22 on the average trade
127 / 5,000coin flips that matched or beat it on the years before 2023
86 monthslongest wait for a new equity high

How to read the score. It has to beat 5,000 coin flips on the 15 years before 2023 (2008 to 2022, kept apart from the years since 2023): the same trades with the side picked at random, so they test the side it takes, not when it trades. The years-before-2023 check and the year-by-year check are scored on those years too: with the coin flips, 60 of the 100 points; the other three use all 18. A high score doesn’t mean easy to hold: read the longest wait for a new high. A score is how the setup did against our published checks on 2008 to 2026; it is not a forecast, and what it does next is unknown. How a score is made.

2008 to 2022: 2,265 trades, $348. Since 2023, the years kept apart: 624 trades, -$64,611.

This strategy's money was on the books by noon and the afternoon gave some of it back; taken by hand, the morning was the trade.

Why it failed: it made money in the fifteen years before 2023 and has lost money since, over 30 or more trades since, so it fails whatever the score. It also scored under half on the years before 2023 holding up, higher costs and a nudge to its settings.

How the 32 is made: clean data 5 of 5, the years before 2023 holding up 0 of 25, year after year 11 of 20, the coin flips 12 of 15, higher costs 0 of 20, a nudge to its settings 4 of 15. Passed is 70 or more with two more checks; Close is 40 to 69, or 70 or more that misses a check; Failed is under 40, or failed automatically (too few trades, or money only since 2023). How to read a report

Break of structure on CL: cumulative net after costs
Break of structure on CL: how far below its last high it sat, with the longest wait for a new high shaded
Break of structure on CL: the strategy against 5,000 coin flipsBreak of structure on CL: net by year, 2008 to 2022 and since

What to do with this

Where it breaks

Where the written rule breaks: its shorts lose in both periods, -$16,681 from 2008 to 2022 and -$48,208 since 2023.

Longs2008 to 2022: 1,141 trades, $17,029since 2023: 346 trades, -$16,403Test longs only →
Shorts2008 to 2022: 1,124 trades, -$16,681since 2023: 278 trades, -$48,208Test shorts only →
Mondays2008 to 2022: 447 trades, -$3,527since 2023: 127 trades, -$18,273Test it without Mondays →
Tuesdays2008 to 2022: 440 trades, -$4,458since 2023: 128 trades, -$14,368Test it without Tuesdays →
Wednesdays2008 to 2022: 470 trades, $4,547since 2023: 120 trades, -$8,274Test it without Wednesdays →
Thursdays2008 to 2022: 474 trades, $9,519since 2023: 131 trades, -$10,460Test it without Thursdays →
Fridays2008 to 2022: 433 trades, -$6,299since 2023: 118 trades, -$13,236Test it without Fridays →
Closed at a set time instead
2008 to 2022since 2023
10:00 AM-$308$2,432
11:00 AM-$6,399-$16,701
12:00 PM$12,025-$33,311
1:00 PM$13,544-$36,935
2:00 PM$18,556-$33,110
3:00 PM$6,732-$52,117
Every trade still open at that time closed there, the ones already out kept as they were.
How it got out (all the years)at its set time 2,131 trades, $488,491; at the stop 758 trades, -$552,754.

Every number above is counted from this test’s own trades. A red edge loses in both periods, a green one makes money in both. Picking the best tile is fitting: test your own version and it is scored as a second try.

Or test fewer days, as we did for this setup (below): only after a wider-than-usual day, or only after a quieter one. Each opens the form with that one change filled in; the run is yours, free, private, by email.

What failed, and what to test next

Per contract, the typical trade was up $360 at its best and down $320 at its worst before it got out, against a stop $660 away.

How the trades moved doesn't point at the stop or the target: no one change to them stands out.

How far each trade went for it and against it before it got out, held against the same trades taken the other way (the side the coin flips take). Read from this test’s own trades; nothing here is run or scored.

What we ran next

The next one. The report points at getting out earlier in the day. This setup still takes trades after that time, so getting out then would also mean stopping new trades earlier: two changes, not one, so it isn’t run.

We tested fewer days. The setups that came near a pass mostly trade rarely, so we kept this one to about half its days, both ways, with one condition (yesterday’s range against the 20 days before it), scored the same way as a second try. Only after a wider-than-usual day: Failed, 27 out of 100, 1,366 trades; 2008 to 2022 $1,223 (154 of 5,000 coin flips as good); since 2023 -$29,369. Only after a quieter-than-usual day: Failed, 20 out of 100, 1,514 trades; 2008 to 2022 $773 (861 of 5,000 coin flips as good); since 2023 -$33,992.

What to try next. Fewer trades. Of the setups that trade least (up to about 122 a year), 15 of 133 came near a pass; of the rest, 5 of 402. A condition that keeps fewer days is the first thing worth testing. A stock index: 15 of the 20 setups that came near were on ES, NQ, YM or RTY. What the setups that came near share →

Check your own trades

If you trade a version of this, the trade audit holds your own fills against the written rule and shows, in dollars, what your part adds or costs. Audit your trades →

A strategy the form doesn’t know goes by email, about a week.

The same setup on the other markets

Run unchanged, at the same settings, on 11 markets (the shelf’s six and five more; of those five, only a pass or a Close has a page of its own). Each one is its own test: picking the market that did best after the fact is how a backtest flatters itself. ES, NQ, YM and RTY are all stock-index futures and move together, so their agreeing is weaker evidence than it looks.

  • ES Failed 13
  • NQ Failed 20
  • YM Failed 13
  • RTY Failed 13
  • GC Failed 16
  • CL Failed 32 this page
  • ZN Failed 13
  • ZB Failed 18
  • 6E Failed 13
  • 6J Failed 13
  • NG Failed 29

One of the setups in ICT break of structure and change of character: does it work?

One setup, tested, every week

The next verdict by email: what was tested, its score, and where it breaks. Free; leave with one click. Nothing on this site is held back for it.

Sent through Buttondown, the newsletter service you join yourself, as Privacy says.

The engine's report, in full

One trade a day, the first signal in the window, on one-minute bars, with one tick of slippage each way and commission. The coin flips are run on the years 2008 to 2022, kept apart from the years since 2023; the rest of the score uses all of them. Tested November 16, 2026, on data to October 30, 2026.

==============================================================
THINRIDGE ENGINE REPORT
==============================================================

SCOPE: FirstRate one-minute data, unadjusted; the rule exactly as locked; nobody checked it by hand.

1. THE RULE AS LOCKED
   setup type  : Market structure
   as you locked it:
     Break of structure, at the settings the form starts with, run again on data to Oct 30, 2026: swing 5; kind bos; window 9:45 AM to 3:00 PM; exit 3:30 PM; bar 5; mode follow; sides Both
     the years from 2023 kept apart, the split every shelf cell is scored on
   as the engine read it:
   exit model  : stop: one tick past the level the setup itself names (its swing, pattern end, zone edge or swept extreme)
               : target: none (time exit)
               : time exit: always kept as the backstop
   filter      : none
   tries       : #1
   bars        : signals on 5-minute bars built from the one-minute series by clock bucket; every fill, exit and cost is still on the one-minute series
   entries     : one trade a day, the first qualifying signal in the window
   history     : 18.8 years, kept apart from 2023 on (as declared)
               : trades dated 2023 or later are kept apart; the coin flips are run on the trades before 2023, the rest of the score on all of them

2. VERDICT
   SCORE   : 32 / 100
   VERDICT : FAILED
   FAILED AUTOMATICALLY : it made money before 2023 and has lost money since
   UNDER HALF THEIR POINTS : the years before 2023, costs, nudging a setting
   THE SIX CHECKS : clean data 5 of 5; the years before 2023 0 of 25; year to year 11 of 20; the coin flips 12 of 15; costs 0 of 20; nudging a setting 4 of 15

3. RESULT
   Trades 2,889   Net -$64,262.80   Per trade -$22.24
   Since 2023     : 624 trades, -$64,610.80
   Before 2023   : 2,265 trades, $348.00
   Win rate 43.8%  (1266 of 2,889 trades closed above zero after costs)
   Exits by type: stop 758, time 2131
   How it splits (every trade, one contract after costs):
                 trades            net     average   winners
   Long            1487        $625.60       $0.42       46%
   Short           1402    -$64,888.40     -$46.28       42%
   Monday           574    -$21,800.80     -$37.98       45%
   Tuesday          568    -$18,825.60     -$33.14       44%
   Wednesday        590     -$3,727.00      -$6.32       45%
   Thursday         605       -$941.00      -$1.56       43%
   Friday           551    -$19,534.20     -$35.45       42%
   Sunday             1        $565.80     $565.80      100%
   A split is something to look at, not a new rule: keeping only the best side or day is a new version,
   and testing it counts as one more try.
   Time in a trade: half the trades last 2 h 59 min or less; the middle half between 1 h 24 min and 4 h 29 min; the longest 5 h 46 min.

4. THE COIN FLIPS (5,000 copies of the rule that pick the side at random)
   Full window  p = 0.3108  (1,554 / 5,000)
   Before 2023  p = 0.0254  (127 / 5,000)   <- the one the score uses
   Counting earlier tries, p (try #1) = 0.0254

5. YEAR BY YEAR (each year before 2023 a window)
   Years 15   profitable 8   profit factor before 2023 / since 1.46
   Largest year 2011 = 4258.2% of the net before 2023
   By year before 2023: 2008 -$9,659.40  2009 -$122.60  2010 -$11,352.00  2011 $14,818.40  2012 $6,391.60  2013 -$9,162.80  2014 $10,274.20  2015 $10.60  2016 -$2,631.00  2017 -$6,880.00  2018 $6,582.60  2019 $3,944.20  2020 -$16,654.20  2021 $8,389.40  2022 $6,399.00

6. COST STRESS (re-simulated)
   1 tick -$64,262.80   2 ticks -$122,042.80   3 ticks -$179,822.80
   net kept after costs at 1 tick -1137.2%   profit factor at twice the costs 0.84   Breakeven 0.0 ticks/side

7. FRAGILITY (5,000 resamples of the trades, drawn with replacement)
   Full   CI -$146,181.80 .. $19,917.20   P(net>0) 0.0648
   Pre-2023 CI -$73,491.00 .. $74,060.00   P(net>0) 0.5012
   bad-case drawdown (95th percentile) / actual 1.40x   Top trade n/a   Top-5 n/a

8. NUDGING A SETTING (the main setting moved 10% either way)
   Net kept on the nudge 0%   Turned to a loss: YES   Settings 4

9. COULD YOU HOLD IT (no points)
   Longest stretch without a new equity high: 86 months (ending 2022-04)
   Rolling 12-month windows negative: 58% of 215   Worst 12 months: -$36,725.60 (ending 2026-10)
   Max drawdown $76,788.60   Median year -$122.60   Years of median to recoup the drawdown: n/a (median year not positive)

10. THE CODE FILE (offered when all five hold)
   [ ] passed
   [x] fewer than 1 in 20 coin flips matched it on the years before 2023, counting earlier tries
   [ ] the range of outcomes on the years before 2023 stays above zero
   [ ] it breaks even at 4 ticks of cost a side or more
   [ ] no single trade is over 25% of the net
   => not offered at this result.

11. HOW THE POINTS WERE COUNTED (each measure, then the points it earns)
   II, the years before 2023: steadiness kept on the years before 2023 (Sharpe ratio) 0.0 (per-trade) → 0 points; money on the years before 2023 → 0 points
   III, year to year: years profitable 0.53 → 3 points; profit factor before 2023 / since 1.46 → 8 points; one year's share → 0 points
   IV, the coin flips: coin-flip p 0.0254 (5,000 coin flips) → 8 points; bad-case drawdown / actual 1.4 → 4 points; top trade n/a → 0 points
   V, costs: net kept after costs -11.372 → 0 points; profit factor at twice the costs 0.84 → 0 points
   VI, nudging a setting: net kept on a nudge 0.0 → 0 points; settings counted 4 → 4 points; turned to a loss: yes → 0 points

12. THE AUTOPSY (where the money came from and went; the rule as it ran, no new try)
   Exits: time 2,131, $488,490.80; stop 758, -$552,753.60
   On the books, before 2023 (net $348.00): 10:00 AM -$308.20  11:00 AM -$6,398.60  12:00 PM $12,024.60  1:00 PM $13,544.20  2:00 PM $18,556.00  3:00 PM $6,732.20
   By 12:00 PM the books held $12,024.60 against $348.00 at the close; the afternoon gave back $11,676.60
   Before 2023 $348.00, since 2023 -$64,610.80; largest year before 2023: 2011 = 4258% of the net before 2023
   Nudging a setting 10%: 0% of the net kept; turned to a loss: yes
   Flat stretch: 86 months without a new high (ending 2022-04); median year -$122.60; years of median to recoup n/a

   The money was on the books by noon: $12,024.60 at 12:00 PM against $348.00 at the close; the afternoon gave back $11,676.60. One year is most of it: 2011 is 4258% of the net before 2023. Longest wait for a new equity high: 86 months, median year -$122.60.
   The one next run, if you want it: the neighboring setting of the primary trigger (10% either way), as try #2. Prediction on file: a plateau under 25% means the neighbor rejects too; this run is to show it. Three such runs at most, then the verdict stands.

13. IF YOU TRADE THIS BY EYE
   This rule's money was on the books by noon and the afternoon gave some of it back; taken by hand, the morning was the trade.
   That is what the record says about the rule as written. It is not what next year says.

WHAT THIS CANNOT TELL YOU: the score assumes this rule walked in
once (see tries) and that your development did not touch the
years before 2023. Only you know both. Not investment advice. No
guarantee of future results. Statistical analysis of a mechanical
rule as submitted.
==============================================================

Raw market data: FirstRate Data (firstratedata.com). Statistical analysis of a mechanical strategy as written; not advice.